The At Beaver Island Lodge

Stunning views of Lake Michigan, amazing food and service, and a top-notch wine selection. This is a true destination that made our trip truly memorable.

This is the perfect place for dining during sunset. We enjoyed our meal outdoors, and it wasn't crowded since we visited mid-week in August. The service was excellent. We both started with the mushroom bisque soup, which was outstanding. My wife ordered the whitefish accompanied by risotto and asparagus; the fish was delicious and not over-seasoned, while the risotto was decent and the asparagus was fantastic. I opted for a ribeye steak, asparagus, and dauphinoise potatoes. The potatoes were beautifully prepared, almost like a pie, and were wonderful. The steak was tender with a nice crust from the grill. For dessert, we enjoyed a pound cake and I had a delightful rum and ice cream parfait. Both desserts were very good. The price is reasonable for a quality steakhouse.

A total waste of money! This restaurant used to prepare local Whitefish exceptionally well. However, the Whitefish I had in July was thin, clearly pre-prepared in triangle shapes, and smothered in an overly sweet lemon curd. All of that for $32.00! Our son ordered the Bison Wellington, which also seemed to be pre-made. When he cut into it, a gelatinous fat oozed out. It was disgusting and overpriced. We won't be returning until new owners take over.

A complete waste of money! This restaurant is known for its locally sourced white fish, but my experience was far from impressive. The white fish I had in July was thin, clearly pre-prepared, and smothered in an overly sweet lemon sauce. All of this for $32.00! Our son ordered the bison Wellington, which also appeared to be pre-packaged. When he cut into it, a disturbing amount of fat oozed out—it was gross! Everything was overpriced for the quality. We won’t be dining here again until there are new owners.

The restaurant has a lovely ambiance and our meal was absolutely delicious. It's a great place for special occasions or celebrations, but even if you're just looking for a good meal beyond burgers or sandwiches, this is the spot. We came in dressed casually and felt completely comfortable. The service was exceptional, and our waitress went above and beyond to ensure everything was perfect!