Picnic Pizza - Big Flats

The pizza was excellent! I dined in and found the price to be very reasonable, between $1 and $10 per person. The food was outstanding, receiving a rating of 5, and the service also earned a perfect score of 5. The atmosphere was equally enjoyable, also rated 5. Overall, a fantastic experience!

I had an excellent experience with the pizza here. I ordered takeout for dinner, and the prices were very reasonable, with meals costing between $1 and $10. The food was outstanding, earning a perfect 5-star rating, and the service was equally impressive, also a solid 5 stars. The atmosphere was pleasant, scoring a 4. I highly recommend trying the Taco Pizza, Ham Calzone, Sausage Roll, Chicken Wing Pizza, Fancy Pizza Slice, Combination Calzone, Sicilian Pizza, and Pepperoni Pizza.

- Meal Type: Lunch - Price per Person: $10–20 - Food: 5/5 - Service: 5/5 - Atmosphere: 4/5

In general it was okay and the pizza didn't taste bad. But I made the mistake of eating in and with the amount of flies crawling up and down my legs and arms and face and pizza box I was not very happy or comfortable. The music was great except that the speaker was right over my head and the room was filled up with too much noise to even talk to your phone let alone talk to somebody sitting across from you. The place was on par with any other pizza place with the exception of the things that I have listed above. For the amount of money for just a single large pizza with two toppings, at $28, I would not go there and buy again. Add to that the flies and the loud music and I definitely will not be returning.

This pizza is quite good, located just a short distance from 17/86. If you're a fan of thin-crust New York/New Jersey-style pizza, this independent and dedicated establishment is definitely worth a visit. I apologize for the poor quality of the photo—I was so hungry that I dove right in before I remembered to take a picture! I really enjoyed the meat lovers slice as well as the broccoli, tomato, and garlic slices.