Hickory Tree Pizza - Chatham

This is a reliable establishment. I recently left a CVS bag in the restaurant containing gift cards I received for Christmas. When I called the next day, Hickory Pizza had set it aside for me to retrieve. They truly saved the day, as the bag could have easily been lost. Thank you, Hickory, for your honesty!

I had my first Hickory Pizza this past weekend, and I think it’s safe to say I’ve found a new favorite spot. This pizza has the New York-style flavor I remember from my childhood. The crust was particularly unforgettable, with just a hint of sweetness that reminded me of freshly baked bread. The cheese-to-sauce ratio was perfect, and they were generous with the toppings.

Hickory Tree serves our family’s favorite pizza, without a doubt. The crust is thin yet chewy, and the toppings are plentiful. We’ve been ordering from here for years. During our most recent visit, we decided to try the cauliflower pizza crust, and we were absolutely amazed! It was so delicious that we couldn't even tell it was made from cauliflower. It has a wonderful crunch, a chewy texture, and fantastic flavor. I can't stop thinking about this pizza!

The best of the best ! They even have fresh dough you can bring home to experience the goodness of there pizza at home.

This is the best pizza in New Jersey! The pizzeria has a cozy underground vibe. When you walk in, you can often see someone skillfully preparing the dough. The flavor consistently surpasses your expectations. They use high-quality ingredients—cheese, sauce, vegetables—and the prices are great too!