Timothy O'toole's Chicago

Timothy O Toole's is a great restaurant that we enjoyed glad that it was close to our hotel during our stay. Service was good throughout our visit with regular check ins as needed. We came on a Sunday and were asked if there was a particular game we wanted to see. Like many bars they have TVs throughout with all the different football games you may want to see on a Sunday. The games aren't too loud so you'll still be able to hold a conversation without trying to compete with a blaring TV. We started with an appetizer that turned out to be very good, the pretzel trio. The pretzel flavor is definitely different since I think they may fry up the pretzel after it's made. The sauces are the stars and all three bring a different flavor balance that you'll enjoy. The burgers were great that we got for our lunch with the Jameson Maple Bacon burger only being available on the weekends and not found on the mainstream menu so it's possible that it's limited time. Very good burger with a syrupy good flavor. We also got the peanut butter crunch burger which was very good too. Our first peanut butter burger and it was good with the sriracha aioli giving it a bit of a kick. Turns out that they have multiple locations with one being closer to me so we may end up visiting that location in the future since this was a good experience overall. Check them out if you get a chance maybe try the Big Timmy challenge that we learned was featured on Man vs Food (I couldn't make it all the way through for sure after reading up on it from the menu but maybe you can conquer the Big Timmy)

Katie was amazing, super fun, and accommodating, the rest of the staff were friendly too! The parm fries are good, you may need to add a little salt and the pomegranate martini was delicious , I had two

Nice atmosphere in the restaurant with a lot going on but the food was terrible. Found a big piece of Saran Wrap in my sandwich which is a bit of a giveaway they’re not made fresh to order. And it wasn’t exactly a little price of wrap. I checked the rest of my sandwich as personally I don’t want to consume plastic. Our waiter got me a new sandwich (this time without the plastic) and not only was it smaller than before but this time the bread just was kinda chewy. My friend who took me there was apologizing that it used to be a lot better and after reading some previous reviews I hope this was just a one off accident but I’ll still never be back. The area is abundant with plenty of other restaurants to try instead Timothy O’tooles.

Great place for a drink to watch a game or get together with friends. The food can be good. If you have any dietary restrictions, be sure to clearly tell your server.They have a large bar with a plethora of seating. Their drinks are fun, they even have their own twist to some classics. On top of that, the staff was as attentive as they could be considering how many patrons they had, which is always a bonus. A+ for service and staff attitude!

Food was excellent appetizer and meals. Services was poor. Ordered amaretto sour and not sure what I got but it was not that. I drank it and never complained. I then asked for a diet coke that I waited forever for. I had no drink for my entire meal and 10 minutes after I was done. I asked many times. Maybe he was new not sure but needs improvement.