Applejack Diner - City of New York

Watch out! The portions of everything are huge. No way we could finish sandwiches or ice cream. Breakfast is more normal but huge sausage and tons of potatoes. As others note it has a huge menu but stuff coming out of the kitchen was all good. No duds. Overall quality is what you would expect in a diner. Breafast fare and lunch fare were good. We never did dinner here. Our breakfast for two was good ranging from $50 to $60 which seems high but hey, it's New York. Lunch was similary expensive as was a late night ice cream dessert. We love this place as it's got a good comfy feel to it and the people inside are VERY friendlhy. I will be back but now I know to order less as more. You won't have much trouble making the credit card minimum of $10 unless you just order a beer!

Very Dirty, dated menu, staff not very professional. Entire experience was disappointing. Will not go back.

It's a bad sign when the host is also the waitress and cashier. 1st issue: the coffee was small, as in really small and only a whopping 3 creamere!! Yes, I could've asked the hostess/waitress/cashier to get more creamer, but by this time, I was just already fed up. The coffee was awful!! I couldn't drink it at all. We asked for water, and the hosr/waitress bought, of course, only 1 water go figure). We must have waited at least 15 minutes, although it's light in how many customers they have. Oh well, here we go.. The omelet was good. It has bits of sausage but enough. I'm unsure of the cheese, it wasn't really melted which leads me to believe that it's something else. The bread was good, if that helps. The hostess/waitress/cashier was very nice, considering it was my first and last time. It is what it is.

Standard diner with Manhattan prices. We got the calamari, kids grilled cheese, burger, and gyro. All items tasted previously frozen out of a bag, calamari, fries, gyro meat, burger meat, all of it. The kids grilled cheese was a pile of the Kraft singles American cheese slices, the stuff that tastes like cheese wiz, and prices were about $25 a meal, the kids grilled cheese I think was just under $16? We were the only ones there at 7pm on a Sunday night.... The staff was nice and service was good. It was convenient after leaving Central Park and prices are standard for the area but won't be back.

Casual. Good service. Food is relatively inexpensive for NYC. Centrally located for pre- or post-performance dining.