Insomnia Cookies - City of New York

Delicious warm cookies avail in vegan options as well. Friendly fast service.

I recommend the Blondie over the Brookie, but everyone has their own taste! Both are always served warm and pair perfectly with milk. The staff at this location is excellent!

White chocolate macadamia nut cookie was excellent. They are warm and soft, but they are expensive for one cookie.

We were thrilled when we finally located the place as we navigated the streets near Fraunces Tavern. Upon entering, we were surprised to find a true hole-in-the-wall establishment that could barely accommodate a few customers. It featured a counter with a menu displayed above and a freezer filled with different ice cream flavors. The friendly African-American guy behind the counter (I mention his race to give due credit) was incredibly welcoming. He greeted us with a smile, handed us the flavor list, and even encouraged us to take a look inside the freezer ourselves. His warm demeanor made the ordering experience enjoyable and put us in a great mood. My girlfriend and I decided on the two-scoop ice cream served on a brownie. The total came to just under $20 for both orders, which is a bit on the pricey side. However, as someone who usually craves a lot of ice cream, I was pleasantly surprised by how full I felt afterward. Another fantastic aspect of this dessert is that it was served on a plate and placed in a cardboard box, allowing us to easily carry it across the street. We found a nearby bench to sit and thoroughly enjoy our ice cream. Discovering this gem for late-night ice cream was such a delight that we promised to return on our next visit to lower Manhattan. Bravo to everyone involved!

I absolutely love Insomnia Cookies! Their cookies are always fresh, and they offer a wide range of options, including vegan treats. My daughter is a vegetarian, so this selection is greatly appreciated. The vegan cookies are just as delicious, and there are numerous choices available. I recently signed up for the rewards program, and now I get a free cookie on my next visit to the store!