Buckeye Slice - Columbus

Without a doubt, Buckeye Slice is the best authentic New York-style pizza spot in town. Locally owned and operated, it’s my favorite place to experience a true taste of New York. Honestly, it serves the best pizza around. The fresh and crispy flavors straight out of the oven are something you owe it to yourself to try if you haven't already!

Has 3 booths and some high chairs along the wall to sit at. We're always on lookout for pizza places to eat at. Refills on drinks. Friendly staff. Locally owned and operated. Enjoyed the giant slice of cheese pizza!!

I have gone here since I was about 5 years old when it was called 'flying pizza ' and stopped going when I was 14. I am almost 20 now and was in the area so I decided to stop by and see if it was still the greatest pizza I have ever tasted. Came in and ordered, sat down and took a bite out of slice of cheese pizza. It is still the same fantastic pizza I remember it being!!! This place will forever be my favorite spot to grab a slice!

Love this place! Deserves more than 5 stars. The pizza, calzones, and garlic knots are to die for, they take me back home to NY. Management is awesome, takes time to tend to his guest and make sure they are satisfied as well as getting to know them. Food here is addicting, I keep coming back!

Best New York style pizza I've had so far in Columbus. It took a long time to find pizza that is shaped, taste, and smells like real pizza should. None of that square business.