Mia Mangia Pizzeria - Depew

If you haven't tried Mia Mangia yet, you really need to. They serve the best pizza around and are consistently excellent. Their sauce is just right. We always ask for extra sauce, and it's perfectly made every time. Without a doubt, it's our favorite pizzeria in Buffalo.

Steak sub was delicious! Got mine with cherry peppers instead of sweet. Its spicy, so be careful. But I highly recommend. Only issue was I got a cup of sour cream with my jalapeño poppers... I order them everywhere... that was a first. And it was awful. Ranch, hot sauce, almost anything would be better than sour cream.

I ordered a party pizza, and while it was a bit oily, it was still quite tasty. It’s nice to shake things up and try a different spot!

If I could, I would give this restaurant a perfect 10! On September 2, 2022, a Friday before Labor Day, I ordered food, and as always, it was phenomenal. The service was equally excellent. I placed my order for the Bills' season opener at 7:40 PM, and before I knew it, I was at home enjoying a delicious meal that arrived at just the right time—once again, the service was outstanding. I would give it 100 stars! I truly love this place, but sadly, I won't be ordering again. I used to be a regular, dining in at least once a month—sometimes more or less often. Their delivery was always great—punctual and hot—and I always tipped well. However, my recent experience has left me disappointed. I had placed an order on July 6, 2021, a Tuesday at 4:30 PM. When I called to place the order, I recognized the delivery girl's voice; she seemed annoyed, as if she shouldn't be working or perhaps would benefit from a babysitter. This negative impression is part of why I no longer want to be a customer. Today, I ordered a small white pizza and a sampler with four extra sauces, totaling about $38. I started checking on my order at 5:45 PM, and by 6:15 PM, I was met with a busy signal for 15 minutes. Finally, I got through at 6:30 PM and inquired about the status of my order. The person on the line apologized, saying my order had just gone out because they were busy. When my food finally arrived five minutes later, I noticed that my extra sauces were missing. The blue cheese and ranch were hot, while my food was merely warm, as if it had been sitting out for hours. I called back to report the missing sauces, and the staff promised to bring them right away. Upon realizing how hot the ranch and blue cheese were, alongside the room-temperature food, I decided it was best not to eat what I received. I called again to demand a refund, to which the staff member replied that they needed to check with the manager first. I insisted on a refund, and eventually, the driver returned with my money and took back the food. I think the owner should know about this experience; I can’t be the only one who has faced such issues.

My wife and I think this is probably the best pizza in the Cheektowaga area, and we are hard critics (sometimes we make trips to Lockport to get our favorites). Not just her reason, but her specialties! Big D Supreme and Chicken Wing Dip Pizza are legit. I think they won some competitions.