Marcella's - East Glenville

Delicious and kind staff Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Good pizza and ice cream. Good for take out because dine in is more of an older crowd. Yet there are about 8 tables in their dining room and they have more than just pizza. Ice cream is Perry’s. Big selection and sizes just pricey. They also have soft serve. They do ice cream cakes and great catering. Could definitely use some remodeling to be more inviting otherwise it’s pretty good. Food: 4

The servings sized are huge and the food is great. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

I hate to do this, but wow, what a disaster. I recently moved back into the area after the better part of a decade and was excited to share the delicious roast beef melts of my past with my wife. We ordered delivery even though we're only ~3 miles away since we've been so exhausted with moving. We were told 45-an hour and it took nearly 1.5 hours. The food was cold, not kinda warm and I'm exaggerating, but cold and inedible. Also, we were given a total that was $5 more than the sum of our items plus tax, so basically they charged us a hidden delivery fee of $5, then of course the driver needs a tip, so I paid $50 for food we threw in the trash. Clearly a lot can change in nearly a decade and what was once a great restaurant has become a shell of its former self.

The pizza was hugging itself. Ordered ahead over the phone with no problems, putting in for some Fried Mushrooms, a small Tossed Salad, and a 6 slice RRP Chicken Pizza. When I got there I did get a tiny bit turned around. When you arrive to pick up you need to go though the front door, but don 't go into the dining area straight in front of you, instead you turn left and go into the deli looking area. I had thought this was a kitchen entrance, so I ended up in the dining area. And to make a point about the deli looking area, for picking up, the room in there is pretty small so you might need to wait outside before trying to pickup if it is lunch/dinner rush. Ended up paying close to $38 for everything, not terrible, especially for that pizza as I would come to learn later. When I got home and opened it all up I immediately sampled the fried mushrooms, and like a can of Pringles, I could not stop. I stood there in my kitchen, still in my monkey suit, just chowing down on those mushrooms without a care in the world. I might have been a little hungry, but those mushrooms were excellent. And speaking of excellent, that RRP Chicken Pizza, woozier! Some pizzas just feel like the components are laying on top of each other, like they are repelling one another, but this pizza, this pizza was hugging itself. The roasted red peppers were as if they homogenized with the cheese, the cheese fused with the bread, the bread had a crispy exterior with a firm build. Every bite had zero toppings or cheese falling off, no mess, all happy. Sadly the salad was found lacking, a bit sour, that Italian dressing was the wrong call for the greens included. Overall this was a delightful pizza creation, and i would totally order it again!