Mama Theresa's Pizzeria - East Meadow

I had a terrible experience at this restaurant. An employee verbally abused and aggressively confronted me because I requested a replacement for a burned piece of pizza. To make matters worse, I noticed staff taking trash from the garbage and placing it near the food counter. In a shocking display, some employees even came out to my car with weapons, threatening me. Other customers witnessed this incident during broad daylight. I didn’t engage in any abusive behavior myself; I simply asked for a fresh piece of pizza. I believe action should be taken against Mama Theresa's restaurant for this unacceptable treatment.

It was the best gift for our mother for her birthday today!! Food was superb!! Waitress was brilliant!! The atmosphere is definitely inviting!!!

I don’t usually write reviews, but I have to say this experience was unacceptable. I ordered penne alla vodka and was disappointed. The chicken didn’t taste good, and the pasta was overly watery for no reason at all. Honestly, the pasta at Olive Garden is starting to seem better than this!

Best pizza on Long Island. Service was great and the pizza was amazing. Will definitely be back!!

Great local pizza/restaurant... LOVE all of these: FILET OF SOLE FRANCESE, CHICKEN VALDOSTANA, FUSILLI CASALINGA, PENNE OREGANATE, SHRIMP MONACHINA CHICKEN MARSALA (pizza slice-meal by itself, delish) Lots of excellent choices, not too many places can say that! Try it out you will definitely agree.