Citarelli's Market - EASTPORT

We decided to have them cater a party because their menu was more diverse than a typical Italian restaurant. We ordered Eggplant Parmesan, Chicken Piccata, Roast Beef with Gravy, Baked Ziti, Pork Tenderloin stuffed with spinach and feta, Grilled Vegetables, Roasted Potatoes, and an Italian Sub. Our guests absolutely loved the food, as did we. Many asked where we ordered from so they could use the catering service for their own events. We will definitely use this restaurant again in the future and plan to visit more frequently for takeout.

Ordered a hero with grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, mozzarella, with balsamic for lunch. It was about a foot long and enough to split with another person if you have a small appetite. The photo only shows half of the sub. Came with a side of macaroni salad but you can pick cole slaw or potato salad if you wish. Would come again to try more.

Citarelli's Market offers fine meets, Italian sausage, lunch sandwiches and breakfast sandwiches. The market is very convenient and it is easy to park. The service is fast and efficient. This market should expand their selection of Italian grocery products. My family enjoys shopping here especially when we don't want to travel to the grocery store.

I recently visited this restaurant and was very disappointed with my meal. I ordered The Marco sandwich with grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, and roasted peppers, but I substituted the grilled chicken for a fried cutlet. Unfortunately, the chicken was tough, discolored, and lacked seasoning. The Mac 'n Cheese was also a letdown, resembling watery cheese sauce with no flavor or seasoning. I was hoping for a hearty dish to warm me up on a cold day, but was left unsatisfied. I hope I don't get sick from this experience. Pray for me.

After returning to my old hometown for the first time in years, I stumbled upon Citarelli's and was pleasantly surprised. The establishment was immaculate, well-lit, and the food on display looked appetizing. The staff, particularly the manager, were very welcoming and seemed to be hands-on in the kitchen. I opted for an Italian hero, my old favorite, and when I mentioned to the manager that I hadn't had a good hero in a while, she went above and beyond by adding extra toppings. I initially planned to eat in my car but decided to enjoy my meal at one of the outdoor tables instead. The hero was massive, filled with fresh and flavorful ingredients like bread, meats, peppers, and veggies. Despite knowing I couldn't finish it, I couldn't bear to waste any of it, so I wrapped up the leftover portion for later. Unfortunately, I ended up stuck in traffic on my way home and used the time to devour the rest of the hero along with a Yoo-Hoo purchased from Citarelli's. Surprisingly, even after five and a half hours, I still wasn't hungry when I finally arrived home.