Nicholas Creamery - Fair Haven

My friends told me about this place so obviously after dinner at the restaurant I had to get the ice cream. The ice is exceptional, but one thing to point out that I didn't know CASH ONLY. You have an ATM there, but if you don't want to pay, then make sure you bring cash.

Making the rounds to all 3 locations, this time Fair Haven. Tried the GOAT and Booskerdoo coffee flavors and loved them. This ice cream is special.

I LOVE NICHOLAS CREAMERY! They make the most delicious homemade premium ice cream! It’s worth the drive! My favorite flavor is peanut butter palooza! They mastered their peanut butter flavor! My other favorites are pumpkin cheesecake, peanut butter brownie, chocolate brownie bake! You have to try them! The brownie pieces they put in their ice cream are so fresh, moist, and chocolaty! I never tasted better brownie pieces in ice cream before! Today, I had the apple crumb, and it was very good! It actually had real apple crumb pieces in it! The chocolate bourbon pecan pie was good, but no where near as good as their other flavors so I wouldn’t get that flavor again. The only flavor I didn’t care for was the brown sugar cookie dough. Their brownie sundae is so good too! They make it with a valrhona chocolate brownie! Make sure you get the large or the pint! It’s worth the calories! I highly recommend Nicholas Creamery in Fair Haven!

Never have I’ve been this impressed inside an ice cream place like this. People up at the counter are extremely friendly. Ice cream and shakes are amazing!! Chocolate Brownie Bake and Boskerdoo Coffee Crunch are the best flavors there. I’m looking forward to doing more business with them in the future!!

The cookies and ice cream here are absolutely delightful! The cookies are perfectly balanced—not too thick but still wonderfully sweet. The ice cream has a fantastic flavor and texture that really complements the cookies. Plus, there's a wide variety of toppings to choose from.