The Orignal Whipple City Pizza

Girl with glasses running the register needs to go find a new job. Her favorite word is “can’t.” Service: 1

It's always hot, fresh and ready to go when they say it will be. Using their website to order is so convenient! Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

This is the second time I’ve ordered from Jay’s. The first time, I called in the order for pick up. I was given a super short wait time, and my interaction at the store took all of 2 minutes from when I was greeted to when I had the pizza in my hands. The second time, I found out they delivered to my address, so I took that route. Again, the wait time was tolerable, even with hunger making every minute drag on. Both times I got a 24 cut, 1/2 ham 1/2 meatball. I would say Jay’s is definitely in my top 10 for good pizza. The dough is the perfect thickness, the sauce is flavorful, and the cheese is the perfect amount of stringiness. It even reheats up nicely the next day, which is a big win for me. The garlic knots are drowned in butter, which was a little too much for me, but past that they were delicious.

I bought a 24 cut pepperoni pizza and it literally made me gag. The crust was doughy the cheese was flavorless. I don't even want to swallow my own saliva after having this pizza in my mouth. They also closed the box over the pizza so it left a dent on every single piece of crust. How do you mess up a simple cheese and pepperoni pizza so bad? I'm guessing the pizza sales are not what pay the rent at this establishment. Do not get pizza here. Ever.

First time ordering here as I pet sit and sometimes order in when I’m at clients houses. Fast service and really good food, wings were perfect and pizza is pretty great too. My delivery driver was wonderful. I’ll be ordering from here again.