Fat Cat Pizza - Lancaster

Food is always great..we were not offered any refills and we sat there fourty minutes after eating and had to ask for our check ...no one asked if we needed anything..if you order out it take hour and half to get pizza so we thought be easier to eat in...they had several empty tables and three dirty ones ...love your pizza but a refill would be nice if we sit there that longwaiting to get food then fourty five minutes to pay for it..

Best pizza I've ever tasted.. the place to go when your craving a slice.. good atmosphere, friendly staff

I went through the drive-thru and noticed they were quite busy, which made us wait a bit longer for our pizza. When it finally arrived, it was fairly good—not the best I’ve ever had, but certainly not the worst.

In the past, I enjoyed their sweet house sauce, but this time it was overly sweet and there was way too much of it, making it nearly impossible to eat. I had to let the pizza cool down so I could lift off the cheese and scrape off the excess sauce, along with some old-looking, pre-bagged diced onions. I also ordered a small pepperoni pizza, but the pepperoni was also underneath the cheese, which made it slimy and greasy. I would have expected the pepperoni to be on top so it could crisp up like most people prefer. Overall, I am very disappointed and dissatisfied.

Our child's school provided them with a coupon for a free personal pizza as a reward for their good performance in school. However, when we tried to redeem it, we were informed that the coupon was from last year and had expired, despite the fact that there was no expiration date printed on it. The manager was quite unfriendly about the situation.