Tiberio's Pizza - Lancaster

Delicious food! I absolutely love the garlic bread, though I forgot to order some this time, haha. The Stromboli is enormous, and I can never manage to finish one.

Mamma Mia serves authentic Italian cuisine, and I hate to burst the bubble of those who think Domino's or Pizza Hut represents real Italian food—it's simply not! If you want to experience genuine flavors from Italy, head over to Tiberios. The only thing left to complete the experience would be a pizzeria that uses a brick oven. Just a thought!

Having dined at this restaurant for years, I can confidently say it's the best in town and a hidden gem in our community. This family-run establishment pours a lot of heart and love into their dishes. They even offer delivery! Whatever you're in the mood for, this place has it all, but for me, their chicken wings truly stand out. The prices are fantastic, and you receive top-notch food along with excellent service.

Food is always delicious and the staff very friendly. You won’t find a better Stromboli in Central Ohio

Tiberios use to be the best pizza place in Lancaster. Now that it has a new owner it is terrible. They said our pizza would be ready in an hour and a half when we got there to pick it up they hadn’t even started it. We were told it would be 20 min. More went back to pick it up the woman said she canceled our order. Very poor way to run a business.