Mystic Meat And Seafood Market

Unreal best sub sandwich I have ever had in my life. Get the Italian or roast beef. Best period

The Mystic Subs in Manahawkin is quite pricey, and I found the food to be very disappointing! I ordered from there on two different occasions, and both times I was let down. I won’t be returning. Save your money and head over to Pietro in Manahawkin for a much better meal at half the price!

I only had a breakfast sandwich, which was just average. This makes me think the owners might need to focus less on piling three eggs onto a sandwich for quantity and more on enhancing the overall quality. I'm open to returning to try their subs, but I sincerely hope the owners realize that customers appreciate a pleasant environment, personal interactions, and consistency from one visit to the next—rather than just oversized sandwiches that require cutting with a knife and fork.

Pietro's food is not good at all; it tastes like cheap dog food. It's truly disappointing.

Fantastic fresh food. Amazing menu!