James Madison House Bar Restaurant

Came here with a group of friends for lunch. The person working was friendly and accommodating. Food was decent and everyone enjoyed theirs. My only complaint would be that it was a bit dark, but it get the impression it's more focused on being a bar with a menu than restaurant with a bar. In 2023, that's understandable. Would definitely go back.

Went there 1st time and last time.. we sat at the bar, since no one greets you when you walk in. The bartenders ignored us after we got out drinks and closed the menus, had to ask them if was could order food. My chicken with a basil cream sauce was horrible, so rubbery and the cream sauce was broken and separated into butter and what looked like cottage cheese. I was very hungry so I chewed threw 1 piece and ate the COLD mashed potatoes,. So sad what the broccoli had NO seasons not even salt and pepper.. I see now why they are always hiring a saute cook on Craigslist,. Not the best spot to hire a cook. The bartenders were busy brown noising 3 locals they both spent all there time with them chatting about booze and wine, what a joke. We never got asked how our food was because they know it sucked, we also had to ask for the bill about 20 minutes after we pushed our plates towards the bar edge. Some lady came out and poured herself a bunch of wine,. Right to the top, not like the 1/2 glasses they sell. Must of been a owner, anyway she looked at my 1/2 eaten dinner and me but never asked if something was wrong.. Closing soon!!!!!!!!.Should be able to cook chicken properly not just boil it to death. I'll try again somewhere else..

Incredible food, bar and staff! I love the James Madison House!Food: 5/5

Newly renovated space looks great. I forgot the waiter's name, but he was very chill.Food: 5/5

We are so thrilled to have this great spot in North Madison. The food is really good, especially the penne alla vodka. It's a wonderful local restaurant with a varied menu and friendly service.