Roxanne's - Mahwah

This place is great. The pizza is good and it can hold a large group of people. I love that they have family sized options. Makes getting the family together easy. Would definitely go back with a large group.

This bustling yet cozy Italian-American restaurant offers a warm atmosphere. The wait staff is friendly and attentive, making for an enjoyable experience every time. There’s always a lively vibe and plenty of seating available. My family particularly enjoys dining on the back patio. Whether you're looking for a quick meal or a leisurely dinner, I highly recommend this place.

Service was great. Food was fine but definitely not 5 star. Ordered the stuffed penne with sausage. Sausage was great but hey it’s sausage and I doubt they made it here) most of the taste I got was cheese. We’ve traveled a LOT and eaten in tons of Italian places both here, in Canada and Europe. Three stars for the quality of the food is accurate.

The food was excellent, and the service was exceptionally attentive. The seating in the sunroom is lovely, but the acoustics are quite poor. When the restaurant is busy, the chatter bounces off the tile floor and glass walls, making it nearly impossible to hear conversations at your table. It leads to everyone having to shout. Some soundproofing would make a significant difference. The main dining area isn’t much better, despite having carpeted floors.

I would not recommend this restaurant. The staff was unprofessional and rude, and the food was bland and of poor quality considering the prices. There was clearly no effort put into the pasta dishes. To make matters worse, the waitress had the audacity to ask for a tip despite not providing any service worthy of it. When I brought this up to her manager, he became annoyed and reprimanded me for not tipping her, even telling me not to return to his establishment. Honestly, I had no plans to come back anyway. Overall, this place is highly unprofessional, and there are so many better options nearby with friendly staff. Save your money and go somewhere else.