East Of Chicago - Marysville

We think it's one of the best pizzas we've ever had! The 30 miles drive worth!

The customer service was excellent, and the pizza was fantastic! We ordered the tower.

I drove to Hilliard to get this pizza. As a child, I used to enjoy East of Chicago in Grove City, which sadly closed in the 90s. I always remembered their perfect pan pizza. After not having East of Chicago since the mid-90s, I wasn't sure what to expect, but I was not disappointed. When I arrived, I saw mostly young staff, but they nailed everything. Both pizzas were made to absolute perfection—just the kind of old-school pan pizza that Pizza Hut used to make back in the '80s, if they had only kept it that way. If I could, I would give East of Chicago 10 stars! Today, I reheated the leftovers in the oven for 10 minutes at 350 degrees, and it was just as delicious as last night. The staff even offered me money-saving vouchers. This was the perfect pizza for a Friday night, and even though it’s a one-hour round trip for me, I’ll definitely be back!

The pizza was delicious! However, what stood out the most was that I requested them to draw a duck on the box. I'm still wondering if that GORGEOUS DUCK is somehow sending its greetings to me!

The pizza was incredible—loaded with just the right amount of cheese and bursting with flavor. My two kids, aged 7 and 5, are usually quite particular about pizza, but they absolutely loved it. The nachos were a hit as always, and the garlic bread paired with that sauce was fantastic!