More Ice Cream - Middletown

This charming and cozy little ice cream shop is a hidden gem. Although I can no longer indulge in ice cream myself, my wife and children thoroughly enjoyed it. It's definitely a worthwhile pit stop if you happen to be passing through Middletown.

The restaurant is beautifully decorated and cute, with a charming Middletown hometown atmosphere. There were a variety of ice cream flavors to choose from, making it a difficult decision for me to pick just one.

The restaurant is beautifully decorated and has a charming hometown feel to it. I was impressed by the variety of ice cream flavors available and had a difficult time choosing which one to try.

Ice cream was delicious, especially the Reese’s parfait. Mr. Jim was incredibly kind and stayed open another ten minutes so we could make it for a sweet treat enjoyed on the lovely front porch.

Stopped here after visiting Crystal Grotto Caverns for an ice cream treat. Staff was friendly and portions were great for the price. Highly recommend banana peanut butter fudge ice cream.