Dusals Italian Pizzeria - Milltown

Place is great. The food is fantastic and the staff is super nice and

I just ordered a pepperoni pizza at around 7:45pm on door dash on 8/11/2023!I ordered a pepperoni pizza and I know whoever did it was trying to pull a prank. The pepperoni is all next to the crust and away from the center…. Fire them now.Iv been ordering from you guys for years and now a customer lost.

Have been eating here since 1999 and the food is always consistently delicious and service is great..Thanks Allana

I'm new to Milltown, having recently moved here from Staten Island, a place renowned for its pizza. Naturally, we were eager to see how Dusals would compare.During a birthday party at my place, attended by about 10 friends from Staten Island, we decided to order from Dusals. We got a total of 5 pies – 1 cheese regular, 1 cheese pepperoni, two bar pies, and 1 regular cheese with pineapple, peppers, and sausage (a birthday girl's quirky request we couldn't refuse).Surprisingly, all 5 pies vanished within about 20 minutes, although it felt like just 5 minutes to me. I reached for a fifth slice and found nothing left, not a single slice even the blasphemous pineapple pie GONE.Do I need to say anything more? A house full of NYC Italian’s went home well fed, and longing for more.Will be trying some of their non pizza dishes soon, and I felt stupid for not ordering garlic knots but next time!

Beware, dear readers, for what was once a crown jewel of pizza perfection has been tragically cast into the depths of mediocrity by the hands of new ownership. A culinary treasure that once graced our neighborhood has been shamefully reduced to a tasteless travesty that would insult even the palate of a child.Imagine sinking your teeth into a pizza slice devoid of any semblance of flavor, as if a novice had been entrusted with the art of crafting this beloved dish. But fear not, for salvation lies less than a mile away in the embrace of Maria’s in Milltown. There, your taste buds shall rejoice in the symphony of genuine flavors, each bite a testament to the craftsmanship of true pizza artisans.Alas, the decline of this establishment is not limited to its flavors alone. Quality has been sacrificed, and service has spiraled into oblivion. The aura of disappointment hangs heavy in the air, much like the stench of failure that now clings to this place. It appears that the new proprietors envisioned an effortless ascent to success, riding on the coattails of their predecessors. Little did they grasp that true greatness requires dedication and hard work. It’s as if they studied the art of failure and executed it masterfully, evident in the barren parking spots that once thrived with eager customers.Allow me, a local, to spare you the agony. Seek refuge at Maria’s, where satisfaction is not merely a promise, but a guarantee. Your happiness and wallet will thank you for steering clear of this establishment that now stands as a monument to disappointment. Let my words be your compass, guiding you away from this regretful pitfall. Your money deserves better; treat yourself to the joy that only Maria’s can provide.