Amazin' Melts - New Paltz

This hidden gem has quickly become one of my favorite dining spots in New Paltz. The sandwiches are absolutely delicious! My wife has a gluten allergy, so we ordered some gluten-free bread in advance (you need to request it 24 hours ahead). I truly love this place. I've tried everything on the menu, and I haven't been disappointed yet. I’m not usually a fan of potatoes, but their homemade potato chips are fantastic!

I had been looking forward to trying this restaurant for a while. I discovered that I could place my order online, which was a nice feature, so I decided to take advantage of it. The screen indicated my order would be ready in 20 minutes, but there were no notifications or timestamps provided when I placed it. I arrived sooner than the expected time and found that the restaurant was quite small, making it a bit cramped at the entrance. With only two staff members working, the service was a bit slow. When I picked up my food, it was ready, but they forgot to include the coleslaw, so I had to ask for it. Overall, the food was good, and the service was decent. My main complaint is that the parking lot is very limited, and the restaurant itself is small, which makes logistics a bit challenging. I'd say it's worth a visit if you're thinking of trying it.

Fantastic food and very friendly staff! I really enjoyed the Buffalo Chicken melt.

Big local shop! We stopped at lunch and are very pleasantly surprised. The restaurant is sweet and the staff was very pleasant and helpful. The sandwiches are delicious and the tomato soup (of course! It was delicious. I enjoyed the homemade chips with the Aioli. We will definitely be back

Had the garden melt. So good. My husband had the Philly cheese steak melt. Also delicious. Can't give 5 stars because they didn't have any chips the day we went and the dipping sauce for the chips looked really good!!