Pizza Collective - New York City

I ordered the Build Your Own Pasta with gluten-free penne and marinara, and it had the most incredible texture and quality.

I ordered the HALF COLLECTIVE PIE and it was incredibly tasty, fresh, and delicious. I loved being able to enjoy a variety of slices. I highly recommend it!

This was hands down the worst meal I've ever had in New York. The pizza (I ordered the one with cherry tomatoes) was completely inedible. The build-your-own pasta was overloaded with toppings, and I had to chug milk to cope with the overly generous amount of red pepper flakes. As for the focaccia, it was topped with what tasted like sand. I would definitely recommend avoiding this place.

The square slices here are absolutely fantastic! This place is definitely worth a visit, as they offer a wide variety of slice options. The buffalo chicken slice was particularly impressive, boasting great flavor and a nice crunch.

Pizza Collective is truly inconsistent. There have been times when I've enjoyed a fantastic slice—fresh, gooey mozzarella and a perfectly crisp crust. However, I've also received a dry, overcooked slice that seemed like it was a day old. Just last night, I got a fresh cheese slice straight from the oven, but it was surprisingly spongy, reminiscent of the pizza squares served in elementary school during the 80s. When they get it right, it’s great, but they definitely need to improve their quality control.