Eddie's Gourmet Pizza - Newburgh

I am extremely disappointed with how mistakes were handled at this restaurant. They refuse to take responsibility if they make a mistake with an order. It appears that the staff I encountered last night were unhelpful. The menu advertised one thing, but the server argued that it was not the case. This will be my last visit to this establishment. They have lost my business and any potential future orders. I will definitely be sharing my negative experience with others.

Great pizza... Friendly staff. Theres not a single person who enjoys Italian food that has not heard of Eddie's gourmet pizza ... Not in this area!

Gross and tasteless..Basically like overpriced amusement park pizza. Never again.

I have been coming here for more than 25 years and the food is always excellent

We had an incredible dining experience at this restaurant! We are from Savannah, Georgia and came here to celebrate my son's graduation. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza for delivery just 45 minutes before closing. Shortly after placing our order, we received a call informing us that they were out of bread for the sandwich we had also ordered, so we decided to go for a Stromboli instead. The staff was very accommodating on the phone and the delivery was incredibly fast. Amazing and delicious food all around!