Bellmore Bagel Cafe - North Bellmore

This restaurant serves the best bagels on Long Island. I have been a regular customer for years and the quality is always exceptional. I have noticed some negative reviews online, but I believe those people must be mistaken.

I absolutely love the bagels, cream cheese, and everything else at this restaurant. The staff is always wonderful. I would say I come here about 90% of the time.

Before I share any negative feedback, I always try to start with something positive, so here it is: I enjoy this restaurant. They have renovated and expanded, and it looks great.

I ordered a chicken salad BLT from Bagel Cafe through ubereats, but received egg salad instead. I called the restaurant and they quickly sent the correct sandwich to my home in less than 20 minutes. I appreciate their accommodation and their sandwiches are delicious. Their bagels are also the best around!

I have never had a better bagel in my life than the ones at this restaurant! They are absolutely delicious and I cannot put into words how amazing they are. I tried a plain bagel with cream cheese, a plain toasted bagel with butter, and a bacon, egg, and cheese bagel, and they were all exceptional. Plus, the most expensive bagel they sell is only $2.30 with tax included. However, the pricing for drinks and other items besides bagels is quite high. I suggest going to the nearby 7/11 for a cheaper drink option. Because of this, I am rating this restaurant 4 stars instead of 5. But if you're in the mood for a fantastic bagel, this is the place to go.