David's Custom Cakes - North Haledon

Oh my God…. Holy cake!!!!! Best cakes hands down! Our wedding was 3 days ago and this cake shop blew our heads off! Our fall themed pumpkin spice wedding cake with apple cider donuts was the best thing I have ever tried in my life! Everyone was raving about our wedding cake and how soft, moist, flavorful and absolutely stunning it was! They made our vision a dream come true and we will continue to buy cakes from them for all our future celebrations. Just outstanding! Their communication was incredible and stress free. Their kindness and professionalism was out of the 1950s! Thank you so much!!!

My wedding cake this week was perfect! So many people at the wedding commented on how beautiful and delicious it was! The entire process was very easy to design the perfect hallowedding cake with the designer. This was the second cake they did for us in the last couple years. The first was for my husband's 50th birthday. That was a replica of his classic car. Both were gorgeous and the tastiest cakes we have ever eaten. At both parties, the guests were raving about the cake. Thank you for making both events so special!

I just wanted to say the cake for my daughter’s graduation/ Disney college program was beautiful exactly what I wanted and I got so many compliments on the cake itself how tasty it was … thank you so much for making my daughter’s day extra special! She absolutely love it !!!!

I ordered a cake for my baby shower. The cake was beautifully made and tasted very good. I’m just disappointed by the fact that the cake was delivered without any type of packaging. The delivery person just handed to us the cake without cover, box which was socking to me specifically in the covid era. cake should be in a box or cover to protect from any dust/bacteria.I had to be careful handling the cake so the doesn’t hit the walls of my fridge since it did not came with a cover.

We ordered our wedding cake here and I loved that I could pick different flavors for different tiers. I’m usually not a cake person but gosh, I actually really enjoyed the Hazelnut Mousse and Mocha Buttercream! The quality and taste of the actual wedding cake was consistent with our cake tasting (we’ve read some bad reviews from other bakeries that got me worried so wanted to point it out) and it was easy enough to pick up the samples if you don’t want to sit through a formal appointment. The only thing I wish could be different is if they can stay open a little later than 4pm. Most people are still at work at that time and they made it clear that they wouldn’t stay open 1 minute past 4pm.