Federico's Pizza On Main Oceanport

I've tried both the regular pizza and the Sicilian here, and I can confidently say that this place is a must-visit in the area. The Sicilian pizza is fantastic and my favorite in the region. The regular slice is also among the top three I've had. Federico's is truly a hidden gem!

This place is fantastic! Without a doubt, it's the best pizza in the area by a long shot. Everything else on the menu is amazing as well!

Federico's is hands down the best pizza in town. The sauce is incredible! I honestly can't think of a single negative aspect about this place. It's been my go-to spot for years!

After Kit's dental appointment, we drove up to Oceanport to check out a new pizza restaurant in the old Enzo's location. It's called Federico's and it's the second location of the Federico's in the Shrewsbury Plaza. Today, Kit tried a plain slice as well as the sausage, peppers, and onions, while I opted for a Sicilian slice and a sausage-peppers-onions slice. My third slice looked like a plain slice but was actually topped with crispy chopped pepperoni, which was a delightful surprise. All the slices were perfectly crisp, and the toppings, cheese, and sauce were outstanding!

This was possibly the worst pizza we've ever had. We ordered a Sicilian, and as everyone knows, it's all about the sauce - but there was hardly any! It was mostly just cheese, and the cheese itself was terrible, like chewing on gum. We thought the plain pizza would be better—it's hard to mess that up, right? Unfortunately, it was the same issue: no sauce, just dough, cheese, and a lot of oil. We’re still trying to sort things out with DoorDash, but I would never have sent out an order like ours, especially considering how different it looked in the photos online. We ended up ordering from a different place. We definitely will not be ordering from here again.