Billy's Italian American - Old Forge

Family of 4 fully enjoyed appetizers, bread, salad and dinner. Crab/scallop cake appetizer was one of the best we ever had. Stuffed Shrimp Special was for dying like the Aubergines Rollatini. Our daughters had the Essens-Ravioli of the Manicotti-Kid, both were delicious. We were too full to taste dessert, but it looked wonderful! Very recommended! Little call! We'll be back when we're in the area!

Absolutely delicious! The food was amazing! The staff was extraordinary! We met the owner and he was super nice! Would highly recommend all our family, friends and all who go to Old Forge! Thanks “Billy’s” for a wonderful evening!

The food is excellent, the service is second to none. The restaurant has a small cozy atmosphere. Casual dress is okay. You need reservations, otherwise you will never come in. they/you will take excellent in-house creations from classic Italian dishes. Good wine beer selection for the area not over price. I've eaten here many times, always impressed. Billy and the staff have created a small gold mine here.

De-lish-US!! and thanks to Billy, a local organization receives a part of the proceeds... fabulous food, great service last night.... so a great experience for such a small space!

If I could put 10 stars out of 5 I would!! I moved out of Old Forge in August 2016 and have only had a fix or two since then... well, Billy and Dylan personally delivered my favorite meal to me in Oriskany today and it is everything I remember and then some Billy is truly the most thoughtful, generous, and wonderful person and business owner I know. Thank you again!! Chicken Mama Mia for the win!!!