Teddy's Old Lyme Pizza Palace

This is about the best pizza they will find near. the only problem is they don't deliver. Let go and drive.

I tried teddys for the first time today. the pizza is solid Greek pizza, but really small for a big one. I thought they gave me the wrong order when I picked up.

Menu is impressive, eating is not. quite expensive for what it is. salate were a sweat. pizza was ok. portions were small, which would be good if that was eating.

Disappointed that when I called to order and wanted to pay, they could not help because they were busy (now or later I will take the same amount of time) food was very good. Feta and spinach pizza especially delicious. Previous review below reflects 2021. Always fast, good food with good value. Everyone was happy with dinner and they are always so nice! Takeout window makes it super easy to pick up.

Really quick service through their service window. Didn't appear to have their inside dining area open. That didn't affect the speed or the quality. Really well done!