Cold Stone Creamery - Pickerington

The Cookie Doughn't You Want Some was great! My first time trying it. Only wish I could've taken off the caramel

Wish they offered more dairy free options other than only the pink lemonade sorbet, however the staff were more than willing to check ingredients of the mix ins for me to make sure they were appropriate and acceptable to my vegan diet. When they weren’t sure, they even read off the ingredients to me. Not only did they check ingredients for me, but they were also extremely friendly and helpful. Employees worked together and I was glad when I asked about ingredients instead of saying “I don’t know”, they were more than willing to check for me.

This is my favorite place Cold Stone. It has a wide range of chocolates from truffles, to large peanut, almond and cashew clusters. Peanut butter cups they call buckets because they are much larger than the famous brand. In addition to the amazing selection of ice combs, my other favorite thing is the candied apples. My special favorite is the Eimerapfel. Dipped in caramel, then covered in a bowl of chocolate and peanut butter with a similarity of their inspiration. It's so delicious. So yes, 10/10 would recommend for ice and treats.

Fresh mixed in front of you. Cheap prices. For what you pay for 2 large blizzards at dairy queen, you can get the cone below and another of whatever flavor. Download the app for rewards.

I absolutely love their ice cream! I always order the Peanut Butter Cup Perfection, but I swap out the chocolate ice cream for sweet cream. It’s delicious! I usually opt for a cup. The only reason I'm giving it four stars instead of five is that sometimes the cups aren't filled as much as they could be. ColdStone serves fantastic ice cream, and I'm a happy, regular customer! If you haven’t been here yet, you definitely need to give it a try. The prices are a bit on the high side, but once you taste the ice cream, you’ll see it's worth it. Plus, when you order, the staff sings a cute song! You can even sample the flavors if you're unsure which one to choose. This location is always clean and well-stocked, not just with ice cream but also with other treats like caramel apples, Frosty Paws for dogs, and a variety of other goodies on display at the counter.