Conicella's Pizza - Pittsburgh

Didn't knock my socks off, but our pizza we just had delivered was good. Medium, red sauce, sausage, mushrooms, roasted peppers. You can see a couple of slices didn't have much on them, while a couple others were packed. The crust was fairly thin and tasty. Again nothing to sing about, but not bad. I'd order again.

Ambiance:I actually tried calling the place 5-6 times over 2 hours to put an order in but it only kept ringing, didn't make sense because when we stopped in there were like 4 people there... We eventually got through though and food was ready within 15-20 minutes. The place itself feels like a tiny shack, almost like they're running it out of an alley. There is NO seating so it's take-out or delivery only. The workers were quite friendly though and seemed like bunch of old italian men. Food: Our favorite part of the meal, surprisingly, was the meatball sub. Maybe one of the savoriest subs i've had in a long time with HUGE tender beefy meatballs drenched in a rich marina and served on a serious french loaf. The price seemed high at $7.50 but it can easily feed two people. Our pepperoni and mushroom pizza was good, nothing special and not gourmet but still tasty. Our crust still had a little crisp despite steaming in the box on the trip home and the sauce has a mild but savory marinara flavor. The best part of the pizza was definitely the hefty cheese layer which you actually had to bite through because it was so substantial. Pepperonis were mild but generous along with the mushrooms. The large can feed about 4 people. This hole-in-the-wall place won't be winning any gourmet awards, there are no specialty ingredients or flashy combinations, but it may win you over with its down to earth charm. Definitely worth a try with the appropriate expectations.

Excellent pizza. Dough, crust, sauce and cheese are on point. Could use a bit more garlic but other than that this is a standout. I'll definitely be back. It's takeout/delivery only. Place is tiny and they don't take credit/debit cards. Other than that it's a must-visit.

Had these guys for the first time last night we are new residents to greenfield very impressed!!! Don't miss his place due to its size and appearance the food is spectacular. The menu is very small, however, if you do something well, why not stick to the basics? Sometimes the most unassuming places are the best! Guy on the phone and guy who delivered were really nice. Quick delivery 30 mins on a Friday night at dinner time! The pizza: very good!!! The crust is crunchy yet chewy and has a nice flavor. Thinner in the middle and thicker toward the crust. Nice browning. The sauce is mild yet flavorful. Not spicy or sweet, just pleasant. Cheese: delicious and plenty of it! Tip: let your pizza cool or else your cheese might slide off!!! My only criticism is that there seems to be more cheese in the middle and not as much toward the crust. My husband got sausage and I got plain cheese I usually don't like sausage but his was maybe one of the best I've ever had!!! My dad got peppers and onions and wasn't disappointed. We also ordered a chef salad I don't think you could've fit one more thing in there very good! We also got a free 2 liter of soda. All of this for like $35...not bad! For us...we liked it way better than Rialto. A must try when in the area!

Best pizza in Greenfield. Food: This pizza is the pizza that looks like it does in cartoons. Reasonably priced. DO IT OR ELSE. Ambience: Get your food and get out. Staff: All you want out of a pizzeria staff in Greenfield. Read between the lines, people. Always willing to give extra dipping sauces! I think they are cash only, you've been warned.