Hickory House - Reynoldsburg

I've had better steak at a roadside greasy spoon. The menu states that they are not responsible for steaks ordered well done, but, while I ordered medium well, it was indeed well done... The steak was so thin that anything beyond medium rare will be well done. Sides were ok, nothing special. Summary Not worth 1/2 the price they charge. Go down the street for much better quality at a better price! Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $20–30 Food: 2 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 3

Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Recommended dishes: Sweet Corn Nuggets

It?s been several years since having a porterhouse steak at this particular Hickory House? My-oh-My! Great service, friendly staff, wonderful portions, and DELICIOUS! The salad, drinks, sides, and the perfectly prepared steak was worth coming back to (California to Columbus, Ohio metro area). Worth every dollar! May I add a star? ?? ??????????

My mom and I were in New Albany for an appt, we live about 2 1/2 hrs away from there so we always like to eat somewhere new that we do not have. We definitely made a good choice!! The food was great, the service was great, the atmosphere was nice and there were 2 major things that stuck out to me... Posted on each table was a note to their patrons about their rules on behavior toward their staff. I have worked in customer service most of my life and this is something that instantly made me know these people care about their employees more than they care about making money so that was nice and then I went into the women's restroom and although someone had been there working since we'd gotten there the restroom was clean and smelled nice. On the sink counter was a basket stocked with feminine products and a bottle of body spray. Way to go hickory house!! We were very impressed ?

I'm not sure what was better, the food or the staff!! The ribs literally fell off the bone and the porterhouse was cooked to perfection. Robin took care of our every need and made us feel at home. 5 Star all around, can't wait to come back!!