Pizzeria New York - Reynoldsburg

This is one of two spots. I usually visit the Pickerington on, but they were closed for oven maintenance. I have ordered before at the Reynoldsburg. This location does not have a seating area. It's only take out. They were friendly and made sure the oderwas accurate. I recommend it. I am not a fan of pizza chains. Tgis is my go to for pizza. I love mom and pop pizza spots. Butdefinitely worth it. I'm a Jersey girl at heart and I grew up eating a lot of pizza from Italian spots.

Thank you all! The People : They have been so friendly and accommodating. These people take pride in their job , are enthusiastic, very invested and enjoy what they do and share their knowledge!!! They offered to re- heat my pie saying ?Youcan?t have cold pie!? Nick even contacted me in well-advanced notice, apologized even though there was no fault ; (I placedorder earlier in the day, where brick oven needed more sufficient time warm; he asked if I wanted to cancel or changetimes. Those Pies: It?s another gem using the family?s original recipe brought from Queens. These are well balanced and tastypies in all dimensions of crust , sauce and cheese to which I?ve tried the plain or cheese pie!!! Even their side salad wasterrific!!! Their menu was larger than I expected , and have heard the appetizers, and wings are also great! It?s highlyrecommended to GET A PIE OR MORE.

The pizza was outstanding, and the staff made sure my order was perfect. It's cooked in a traditional wood-fired oven, and during the baking process, a small piece of charred material from the top of the oven fell onto my pizza. When they pulled it out, they noticed the issue right away and promptly remade my pizza to ensure I had a great experience. This level of attention to detail and care will definitely bring me back to this location many times in the future.

BEST PIZZA IN OHIO! I discovered this place while giving birth to my twins. I’m originally from New Jersey, so I have a different preference for pizza! I love their pie cut into 8 slices. The food was fantastic, and the prices were very reasonable! This is now my go-to pizza spot every week. Come grab a slice of pizza! The cheesecake was amazing, and I’ll definitely be back!

I expected more. We're from Brooklyn and have been craving the familiar taste of authentic NY pizza. While the pizza was tasty, the dough was chewy and slightly undercooked. I just had higher hopes based on the better reviews.