Tyler's Pizzeria Bakery - Reynoldsburg

The pizza was delicious, and the service was incredibly friendly. Be sure to try the pastries! I enjoyed a cinnamon croissant and took home some blueberry chocolate chip cookie bars. Everything was fantastic!

My group is visiting from out of state and we decided to pick up some pizza to take back to our hotel. The employees were incredibly friendly and made us feel so welcome. The pizza and cheese bread were both delicious!

I'm really disappointed to have to leave such a low review. Tyler’s used to be my go-to for a five-star pizza experience, but my recent visit just a few days ago—my first since 2020—was quite poor. Everything that made Tyler’s pizzas delicious seems to have changed. The crust was no longer light and airy, and there was a noticeable lack of cheese and flavor. I spent $40 on two pizzas that were definitely no better than what you’d get from Little Caesars. I ordered two pizzas with double toppings, which meant I paid extra, but they arrived bare and dry. The crust was thin and overly chewy, almost as if it hadn’t been made correctly, and there was barely any sauce or toppings. It's really disappointing. I love supporting small independent businesses, but I won’t be returning to Tyler’s.

I found me a very good pizza place it is it is worth 20 minute drive to get here

We ordered a pizza that was awesome as always. Wasn't planning on getting pastries but they were giving samples of cinnamon rolls,so I surprised my son and husband with them. Never disappointed thank you.