Sweetfrog - Sayville

I absolutely love the variety! It felt like I was Willy Wonka in a frozen yogurt shop. We definitely need one of these in Valley Stream!

Place is great. But the staff are rude. Google says closes at 9:30pm so I place an order at 840pm only for my order to get cancelled from their end and when I try to call at 845 no one answers the phone. Hmm bad business. This owner will call you non stop and text you! Harassment I think so! I’m never ordering from sweet frog again

It was quick and easy to get my frozen yogurt. It was delicious. I love being able to throw on as many toppings as I desire.

Every time I visit this place, it’s dirty. The machines are never fully frozen, and they’re often just liquid. The floors are a mess, with yogurt spills in front of each machine. The machines themselves look like they haven’t been cleaned in ages—moldy and gross—as if they aren’t wiped down at night. I can’t bring myself to come here anymore. I’ve tried to give it a chance, but it’s just not worth it; it makes me feel sick after I eat it. This is the worst SweetFrog I’ve ever been to. Based on past reviews, this seems to be a recurring problem. Regardless of how busy or slow it is, the frozen yogurt should be frozen—plain and simple.

The restaurant is absolutely beautiful and spotless. Their frozen yogurt is incredibly delicious and definitely the best I've had so far!