Commander Cody's - SHELTER ISLAND

The food was good. Evrything was delicious. If you are from the south-east region, I would not recommend the crab cakes. Hold on the shrimps or other clips.

The seafood is great. It has a good soul. Real seafood, also fresh. And supplement with blues and soul music.

Great dining experience! Delicious food prepared right before your eyes. Fish and chips was awesome and bbq ribs and chicken and scallops and ... in other word everything. Note that, this is a BYOB place

This is a relaxed and inviting spot. A couple of things to note before you visit: they only accept cash, and you'll need to bring your own drinks. I absolutely loved the fried flounder sandwich and really enjoyed the mussels. However, I found the baked clams to be a bit too watery for my liking. Overall, the vibe is really cool and the soul food is fantastic. I would definitely go back!

Absolutely fantastic—definitely a five-star experience! This is hands down the best spot on Shelter Island. Having grown up on Long Island, I have to say this is the only place that makes me feel at home on the island. I know Stacy has put a lot of effort into maintaining the original vibe, but it just doesn’t resonate with me. I used to visit Chequit, and it was quite disappointing. I left that place and came here, and it truly saved my birthday! I’m so thankful this place is still around! Big thanks to Jimmy and Amanda!