Strathmore Bagels - Shirley

The breakfast sandwiches are absolutely delicious, and there’s a variety of bagel flavors available in the display case. The bacon was perfectly cooked and crispy. The service was efficient, and our food was served promptly. Coffee is self-serve, with a wide selection of flavored creamers to choose from. There are a few tables out front if you prefer to dine in. I would definitely return!

I absolutely love their bagels! Most of the time, I'm served by Karen, who is incredibly friendly, always gets my order correct, and makes the best egg sandwich!

Delicious sesame bagels! I was really in need of a change, and despite being extremely busy, the staff took the time to help me with my invoice. They were very kind and accommodating.

Large Bagels Sandwiches and Breakfast Buffet Friendly Staff Always Smile Every Day When You Always Clean Place Always Really Clean Best Place On Long Island

Update: since leaving my last review 5 months ago, the store has definitely turned around. We have been back and our orders have been correct everytime. Food is great and the workers are polite helpful. Thank you for making these changes! Old review: This was a regular place my family would visit when it was previously Strathmore bagels. The food tastes good and portion sizes are reasonable. When the new owners took over, they were very busy as everyone in town was checking the place out. This resulted in wrong orders, long waits and disorganization. It was understood that with any new business comes a surplus in customers and we stayed true to visiting this bagel shop. However, since then everytime my family orders from this shop- our order is either wrong or there is something missing from our order. This isn't a one time thing and we've tried to overlook it because we do love their food but it becomes a problem everytime we order. If we don't open every single sandwich in the shop...we go home with something wrong or a missing item. We love their food and if they could fix this issue we would return..but at this point it's becoming unworthy of the hassle.