Cookie Jar Bakery - Shorewood

Since our favorite bakery closed we've been hunting for another great local sugar cookie. I found this place through Google. I was so happy to find an amazing frosted sugar cookie here! The staff is very friendly they have adorable childrens books cookie jars for sale!!

The best chocolate chip cookies in the Midwest are made here. I love cookies. These are THE BEST there is. The snickerdoodles are outstanding as well. The store is adorable and the staff is always friendly. There is not a mediocre item in the store.

I made a last-minute order for cookie monster themed cookies for my sons first birthday. One dozen for the dessert table and one dozen to be individually packed for party favors. they turned out perfect everyone loved them they look so cute and we’re absolutely delicious I can’t wait to have an excuse to order from here again I highly recommend them!

Came back to try after the closing of Cookie Jar Bakery.. cookies are not the same. Not as good.

Local bakery with sweet treats including their main cookies (chocolate chip, peanut butter, snicker doodles and oatmeal raisin) plus lots of other goodies. Not quite as spectacular as the original owners recipes but still highly recommended.