Pirates Pizza - South Orange

Large wings, amazing garlic knots and excellent pizza! This place is a favorite

I’ve been coming here for years! Visiting this place at least 2-3 times per week since the pandemic struck and overall, they’ve been doing their thang! The pizza-by-the-slice options are more than adequate: 3-5 pies laid out with popular toppings. If you want something less popular, just ask for your plain cheese slice to be built-as-you-want. …like what’s better than chicken/broccoli Alfredo?? A great team of ‘pirates’ — seriously, you couldn’t ask for a better team.

Friendly and very accommodating staff! Generous portions and very reasonable prices! We will visit again the next time we visit our daughter at Seton Hall!

I absolutely love the food and service at Pirates Pizza in South Orange, New Jersey. Their pizza is fantastic, especially the buffalo chicken pizza—it's truly delicious! The atmosphere is inviting, and the place is consistently clean, no matter how busy it gets. The staff is efficient, and their delivery service is always on time. I highly recommend checking it out for a great meal! – Greg

I absolutely love the customer service here! The food is consistently fantastic, and you have to try the buffalo dish—it's a must!