Mariela's Pizzeria - Sparta

I wasn’t expecting much, but I decided to try the pizza, and it turned out to be a pleasant surprise. We ordered two pizzas and some fettuccine Alfredo. Everything was fantastic, and we felt it was a great value for the price. I even reheated the leftovers for lunch today in the oven, and it was still delicious!

I absolutely love the pizza here, particularly the BBQ chicken pizza. However, I've encountered some issues with their hours; the restaurant has been closed during their scheduled operating times, which makes it hard to know when they're actually open. I've had to place a few orders through the Slice app because they weren't open. Aside from that, everything I've tried has been fantastic!

We had an amazing experience! My wife and I grew up in New York City, constantly searching for genuine Spanish food, and we finally found it! The empanadas, rice and beans, tortillas, pico de gallo, and salsa verde were all homemade and incredibly delicious! This is truly authentic Guatemalan and Mexican cuisine. We also learned that they will be getting their fleet license in a few weeks and will specialize in margaritas! We can't wait to return!

Mariela had a birthday party for our two guys, everything was perfect (we order them regularly and always talk about how great the food is!, food was great, reasonable prices and the owner is the sweetest. Very recommended!

Really great pizza! Been in Sparta since 2001, my husband and I something worth buying in town! My husband doesn’t have to get pizza in Essex County anymore!