Mccolley's Irish Pub - Spencerport

Was very disappointed with Wick and Beef. Was very apparent that it was not fresh Cut Beef dry and stiff . Sad over$20 with tax and tip. —— just the sandwich

We've been there twice, and even on a Friday night the wait isn't very long. The wings are great- just the right level of being crispy and evenly coated with sauce (instead of it being in a puddle at the bottom of the basket). I had the chicken pot pie. It is a huge serving I took home a good portion of it. My husband had the Bison burger was very happy with it. This place is a gem in Spencerport. Edited to update- now it's May 2024 and we're still coming back. The menu has been updated the food is still great. This time we tried boneless wine, the fried cheese curds, I had the dill pickle pizza, he had the Cuban sandwich, and our friend had the loaded Ruben baked potato with French Onion soup. Everything was great.

We were there for a party, so it wasn't like it would have been if we went for dinner.

Best little pub in town for food, drinks and atmosphere.

4/16/2024 For the first time in four years I had bad service and was treated and made to feel like I was not welcomed by the bartender , I did not know her first time with her waiting on me.