Market Street Diner - Sun Prairie

Market Street Diner offers a contemporary twist on the quintessential all-American diner experience! It’s vibrant, nostalgic, and the partnership with Carl's Cakes enhances the overall charm...

I want to take a moment to express my gratitude to Market Street Diner. They played a significant role in providing Meals on Wheels in our community, and I’m really saddened that our community...

"This review is a bit different because it's about the pre-prepared Thanksgiving meal they offered this year. As someone who chose to stay home instead of going out for the holiday..."

We decided to try something different instead of our usual fare, and we were pleasantly surprised by how delicious and unique the meal turned out to be. It's clear there’s a creative genius in the kitchen at this diner. The Italian Turkey BLT isn't your typical club sandwich. The focaccia bread is fresh and made right on-site, the bacon is perfectly crispy (because let’s be honest, bacon makes everything better), the tomatoes and lettuce are crisp, and the hot, shaved turkey grilled on the flat top is amazing. The pesto mayo adds a delightful savory flavor that I’ve never encountered in a BLT before. You can always tell when a restaurant puts a little love into their food, and this place definitely does. With friendly service to top it all off, this hidden gem is truly special. Keep up the great work, and we will certainly be back! Don’t pay attention to the one- and two-star reviews; some people just need something to complain about.

Market Street handled all the catering for our wedding, including food, drinks, and even the cake. It was a relief to have a single provider for all three aspects instead of juggling multiple vendors. We worked with Jamie, who made the process smooth and hassle-free. During the reception, everything was executed flawlessly: dinner was served on time, the cake and cupcake display was set up just as we envisioned, and all the food was delicious! Plus, the staff at our event were incredibly friendly, helpful, and a pleasure to work with. Highly recommended!