Amici Pizza Pasta - Tannersville

Tony's has been a beloved fixture in East Stroudsburg for ages. They recently expanded and opened a new location, but unfortunately, a fire led to the temporary closure of the original spot. Normally, I would get my pizza from the other location, but I felt drawn to visit this one since I've been missing the original so much. The pizza here is thin and crispy, and it's incredible. The sauce has a natural sweetness with a hint of tartness, complemented by lovely garlic and basil flavors. The prices are comparable to other pizzas in the area, but their quality far surpasses most. I'm eagerly anticipating the reopening of the original location this spring!

We had dinner here during our stay at the Great Wolf Lodge, which is just a few minutes away. For a group of five, the total came to under $40 (not including tip), and the food was excellent! The staff was friendly, helpful, and quick. We will definitely come back the next time we’re in the area.

I discovered this restaurant just a 10-minute drive from the Hampton Inn and Suites, and it was definitely worth it. The pizza was delicious, and the cheesesteak was fantastic!

Love Tonys pizza!!! Best pizza on the mountain hands down! Can’t get pizza from anywhere else, drive past about 10 spots just for Tony’s.

The food is just awful. It’s bland and flavorless. It’s like they took the menu of a real Italian pizzeria and just decided to copy with no knowledge on how to actually make anything. Their marinara alone was like watery Italian salsa and their white pizza was just ricotta and mozzarella because apparently they are too cheap for some garlic or basil. Their zeppoli was was a joke and I’ve not seen something this bad since the one time I went to the Olive Garden. This is a place to avoid.