Pizza Mia - Tinton Falls

I hosted a New Year's Eve dinner at this restaurant for about thirty people, and everyone raved about how delicious the food was. They even baked fresh rolls for us. We've dined here four times now, and the food has been fantastic every time! In response to the reviewer who mentioned an issue with the pizza crust: I’m sure if you had brought it to their attention, they would have resolved it. Without a doubt, this is the best Italian restaurant in the area!

I haven't dined in the restaurant, but I'm a frequent customer for home delivery. The Sicilian pizza is outstanding—definitely the best sauce I've ever had! The hoagies are fantastic as well, loaded with plenty of meat and cheese, and just the right amount of oiliness. I recently ordered a Sicilian pizza and an eggplant rollatini.

We got out last night. Penne with vodka sauce and chicken, cavatelli and broccoli, and sausage and pepper pizza. Everything was great, the Cavatelli and Broccoli were especially great. The service was also good, the Lord who raised me also came from behind the counter to keep the door open to me when I went out. We'll be back, "you'd like to dive in. Nice and open, clean. Anne

The staff are incredibly welcoming, the food is outstanding, and the dining room is absolutely stunning, complete with a live singer. Overall, I felt right at home at Pizza Mia; they truly treat you like family.