Totowa Pizza

Soooooo.... Disappointed and dissatisfied tonight.I ordered what I thought would be a Sicilian Square pie.Well, my search still continues to find an authentic Sicilian pizza.This so-called Sicilian pizza was watery, somewhat greasy, and nowhere near the crispy airy 1-1/2 thick True Sicilian. Put it this way I was able to eat 7 slices.I've tried about 6 different pizzerias, and still nothing.I've had their eggplant sandwich and hot mussels, and I must say the sauce was pretty good. Also, the quantity and freshness were there.

Terrible attitude. You walk in here and there is no effort to make you feel like a paying customer.

We have been ordering from Totowa Pizza since they opened. Tonight we had a Grandma Pie, it was amazing. I can’t say enough how good the food is from here! Our granddaughter was just born yesterday and we will be very busy, so Totowa Pizza will be catering our Christmas dinner this year. Our whole family loves the food! Thanks Totowa Pizza!!

My plain and pepperoni pies were both extremely burnt. normally i don’t mind when it’s slightly burnt, but this severely altered the flavor and my whole experience with the place.

Very impressed with Totowa Pizza! I had my rehearsal dinner there. The food was great and the service was even greater. I absolutely recommend Totowa Pizza!