Montauk Seafood Company

Montauk has been lucky to have this new fish market in the city. it is clean as a pfeife, and the fish is as local and fresh as it gets. peterson makes it easy to snap everything they need to put together a minute, no fuss, gourmet menu that will be sure to impress their guests. it is obvious that the owners take much pride in their business. I will be a recurring customer. they have the best garnel and cocktail sauce. in the did, everyone in my family agrees that it is the best we ever had!

Fresh Local Seafood Hand Picked by Wes Daily.We also enjoyed the Steak he carries..highly recommend this Market!!!

Fresh, local delicious fish served up by the nicest duo. Had amazing clams that I steamed, and we grilled fresh tuna on the bbq. That and the chunky flavorful fish dip made for an outstanding dinner. Thanks Peterson's! They plan to be open year round, which will be great for Montauk.

Really cute little fish store right in downtown Montauk. I was happy to finally check it out today and I will definitely be back. Lots of locally caught, fresh fish. Highly recommended!

Stopped in and grabbed some swordfish, little necks, and shrimp. Outstanding quality and super friendly staff.