Vinny's Pizzeria - Village of Herkimer

Almost everything we've had is delicious. The subs are huge! This is our Friday fish fry go-to. The chicken riggies were ok; chicken was a little dry, and some of the noodles around the outside of the dish were dry. No complaints about anything else, though! The indoor seating was closed when we went, but we were doing takeout anyway. They get very busy for a reason!

They were quick and accommodating when I called in. Had a turkey sub that was good and a plain cheese for the kids they were happy with. Overall good spot

Favorite place in Herkimer which has a surprising amount of pizza

First time trying their wings and unfortunately I think I got someone else's order as they weren't the flavor of wings I ordered. They were okay but not what I was expecting. It was a busy Saturday night but the staff seemed calm and enjoying work. I ordered ahead and thought 45-55 minutes would be enough time to get a simple order together but it ended up taking closer to 75 minutes because we were waiting on the fries and guess what... Their fries were worth the wait! I wish I would have gotten more ketchup when I asked but she assured me there was some in the bag. She was right three ketchup packets supplied about 1/5 of the fries with some color. Luckily, the fries were amazing without anything but could have been next level addicting if I had something to dip them in. I didn't mind waiting and watching the pizza making operation but I would probably stick to a slice next time so I can get in and out.

My go to place for lunch when im at work. Always fresh food, prices are great, and servings are big.