Casey's - Watseka

The pizza lacks consistency, and it’s clear that the kitchen staff aren't following the measurements provided. There's an entire layer of uncooked cheese, making it almost inedible. I don't understand how they expect anyone to enjoy this.

Casey's usually provides a good experience, but our recent visit was disappointing. Pictured are the two pizzas we received the other night, and I’m not sure what went wrong.

Many of the kids believe this is the best pizza around, and I completely agree! The pizza is excellent, and I really appreciate that they offer affordable delivery. I can always count on my tip being put to good use by the delivery person. They also have an amazing variety of snacks; my 17-year-old is always eager to find an excuse to go there and would happily walk across town just for it! The chocolate-covered rice crispy treats are a particular favorite in our household.

I’ve had a disappointing experience with this restaurant's delivery service. Every time I call to place an order for delivery, I'm told they aren’t doing delivery, despite their claims of being available for it. I won’t be ordering from them again. I’m baffled by their 4.2-star rating when they clearly misrepresent their delivery availability.

This is my favorite Casey's! The staff are always friendly and the pizza is excellent