Amore Pizzeria - Zionsville

The pizza has the perfect crispy texture, and the flavors are just right. The food is absolutely amazing and truly represents New York style pizza. If you've had authentic New York pizza, this one is almost as good—delicious enough to earn a 9.5 out of 5 stars!

I’d rate the pizza a solid 6.9 out of 10. It had a nice flavor but was a bit overcooked, and my main complaint is that it was small and pricey for what you get. It cost $16.00 (including tip) for a drink, a small pizza, and some breadsticks with sauce. If the pizza had been larger, I would have given it a 7.2! The breadsticks and cheese were fantastic, though! I gave 5 stars for the overall setup, along with the cookies, pizza, pasta, calzones, and salads – they offer a little bit of everything. The staff was friendly and attentive. Overall, it's definitely worth a visit if you're in Zionsville. Next time, I'll try a whole pizza and see if it improves!

Excellent service and food! The lasagna is outstanding. I’m Jeff from New Dawn Tree Experts, and I highly recommend this restaurant.

It is a well-known fact that I love a good NY style pizza, and this place delivers. The Risotto balls were also a fantastic appetizer, and the black and white cookie was a great NY way to finish the meal. I'm definitely back.

Ever since I was a kid, Amore was my absolute favorite pizza place to go. I’ve watched this place change so much over the years, and it will always be my favorite! I always rant and rave about the pizza and how friendly the workers are. Hell, even my mom had her rehearsal dinner here over 10 years ago. The food has never gone downhill like you would think with businesses being open for so long, it’s just constantly getting better. I came in today because I’ve had a craving for their large pizza and decided to treat myself. The men behind the counter were so nice and friendly and just made me feel so welcome! One of them recommended I try the chicken parm over penne noodles with salsa rosa (alfredo and red sauce mixed) and oh my lord, is it amazing! Thank you Amore for bringing me so much joy through the years and for many more years to come! Shoutout to their amazing employees who are working so hard and making today’s experience wonderful!